Shes Got No Name Review: Zhang Ziyi Suffers Stoically in a Stately Historical Melodra

Publish date: 2024-07-31

Peter Ho-Sun Chan's sweeping period feature is based on the true story of a woman accused of murdering her husband in 1940s Shanghai.

Giving the traditional, star-driven period epic a gloss-coating of topicality, Peter Ho-Sun Chan’s “She’s Got No Name” is based on a notorious real-life murder case that unfolded against the turbulent backdrop of 1940s China. And although it’s probably most notable for providing Chinese actress Zhang Ziyi with a remarkably de-glammed central role, it is the setting, rather than the sincere but only tentatively feminist storyline, that will likely give this handsome, lengthy movie its international appeal. The re-creation of mid-century Shanghai remains impressive even as Chan’s evident admiration for his heroine’s survival instinct starts to become rote, locking Zhang into a screenplay (co-written by Shi Ling, Jiang Feng, Shang Yang and Pan Yi-ran) that gives plenty of depth to her character’s anguish, but little breadth to grow. 

Related Stories

A hand holding up a controller into the air VIP+

Why the Video Game Industry Can’t Shake Its Struggles

HOLLYWOOD, CA - FEBRUARY 24: Actor Daniel Day-Lewis, winner of the Best Actor award for "Lincoln," poses in the press room during the Oscars held at Loews Hollywood Hotel on February 24, 2013 in Hollywood, California. (Photo by Jason Merritt/Getty Images)

Daniel Day-Lewis Officially Ends Retirement From Acting for Son's Film 'Anemone'

Zhang plays Zhan-Zhou, a poor, illiterate working-class woman with a birthmark grazing her forehead and cheek, whom we meet as she scurries from her alley tenement and onto a trolley car, trying to avoid attention. She is clutching a large canvas bag, stained by a spreading bloodstain — from the beginning, there is little doubt that she committed the crime for which she will soon be arrested by showboating Deputy Police Commissioner Xue (Lei Jia-yin): that of murdering and dismembering her husband (Wang Chuan-jun). His head, and a fish knife used in the killing, will never be recovered.

Popular on Variety

When Zhan-Zhou killed her pawnbroker-turned-luckless-gambler husband — nicknamed “Big Bear,” which is appropriate for how he looms over his timid, downtrodden wife — it was 1945 in occupied Shanghai. But that was also the year the Japanese puppet government was ousted and a new regime installed, during which the courts, in an effort to distance themselves from the prior administration, took a new look at certain high-profile cases. As Zhan-Zhou is tried and retried for this capital crime, Xi Lin (Zhao Li Ying), an almost cartoonishly glamorous local reporter and playwright, takes up her cause, influencing public opinion with her columns and performances, and contributing to the then-novel idea that, when it comes to ongoing domestic assault, there might be different shades of “guilty.”

As Zhan-Zhou, Zhang is the stoic, bloodshot eye of the storm, having the dissociated air of a long-abused wife terrified not only for her life but for her afterlife too. One of her crime’s grislier aspects — the post-mortem decapitation — is explained by the ill-educated Zhan-Zhou’s mystical belief that this was how she could prevent being reunited with Big Bear in their next incarnation. But with Jake Pollock’s careful cinematography almost weighed down by its earnest attention to Sun Li’s lavishly stage-managed production design, it’s up to the supporting cast to generate most of the momentum. Even if some, like Xi Lin and Song (Jackson Yee) a fortune teller prone to uselessly cryptic pronouncements about Zhan-Zhou’s fate, are rather tokenistic representations of larger forces or factions.

Commissioner Xue, a handy avatar for the despised Japanese collaborator class, falls on hard times after the Nationalists take Shanghai and nurses a personal grievance against Zhan-Zhou as the obscure architect of all his woes. But there are decent men too, such as Ho (Da Peng) Zhan-Zhou’s locksmith neighbor who witnessed Big Bear’s abuse. And there’s Ye (Fan Wei, giving one of the film’s most sympathetic performances), the accused woman’s new attorney, who comes to a deeper understanding of the scourge of domestic violence — especially as it may pertain to his beloved daughter, who has recently married into wealth.

The subplot about Ye’s daughter establishes how spousal abuse can flourish in the gilded cages of the moneyed classes as much as in the tatty slums of the impoverished. But not all of Chan’s film is as subtle or clear-sighted. There is much less context, for example, given to the second change of regime that occurred during the span of Zhan-Zhou’s story — the 1949 Communist overthrow of the Nationalists — even though, at one point, we visit a labor camp in 1951. This de-focusing contributes to the slackening pace in the last third of this never-very-pacy film, and to its realistic, but nonetheless anticlimactic impression that however much we might admire its reticent heroine, her story is less revolutionary within the grand sweep of Chinese history than it is a small, poignant anomaly. 

Read More About:

Jump to Comments

‘She’s Got No Name’ Review: Zhang Ziyi Suffers Stoically in a Stately Historical Melodrama

Reviewed at Cannes Film Festival (Out of Competition), May 23, 2024. Running time: 150 MIN. (Original title: "Jiang Yuan Long")

More from Variety

Most Popular

Must Read

Sign Up for Variety Newsletters

By providing your information, you agree to our Terms of Use and our Privacy Policy.We use vendors that may also process your information to help provide our services. // This site is protected by reCAPTCHA Enterprise and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Variety Confidential

A Variety and iHeartRadio Podcast

ncG1vNJzZmiukae2psDYZ5qopV9nfXOAjp%2BgpaVfp7K3tcSwqmirmJrAbrPOrWSnp12jrq6xjKucr6GVrHq7tMCnnmayma62bn2RbG1pamJufnZ7